• About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Careers
  • Schedule
What's On Tap Weekends
ON NOW
What's On Tap Weekends Listen Live
WTMJ
Sunday, August 23, 2026
73.4 °f
Milwaukee
66.2 ° Mon
66.6 ° Tue
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Local
    • National
    • Crime
    • Government
    • Decision Wisconsin
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Education
    • Features
  • Weather & Traffic
    • Interactive Weather Radar
    • Interactive Traffic Map
  • Sports
    • Brewers
    • Bucks
    • Packers
    • Wisconsin Badgers
  • Shows & Podcasts
WTMJ
  • News
    • Local
    • National
    • Crime
    • Government
    • Decision Wisconsin
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Education
    • Features
  • Weather & Traffic
    • Interactive Weather Radar
    • Interactive Traffic Map
  • Sports
    • Brewers
    • Bucks
    • Packers
    • Wisconsin Badgers
  • Shows & Podcasts
No Result
View All Result
WTMJ
No Result
View All Result

Did John Wayne Gacy have more victims? Former attorney points to Wisconsin cold case

Elisabeth MontemurrobyElisabeth Montemurro
August 23, 2026, 12:01 pm
in Homepage Showcase, News, WTMJ Conversations
John Wayne Gacy mug shot

A police booking photo of serial killer John Wayne Gacy at the Des Plaines Police Department in December 1978. (Photo by Bureau of Prisons/Getty Images)

In a new episode of WTMJ Conversations, Libby Collins revisits one of America’s most notorious murder cases through the eyes of one of John Wayne Gacy’s former attorneys.

Karen Conti represented Gacy during part of his death penalty appeal. In her conversation with Collins, Conti said she believes there may be more victims beyond the 33 young men and boys Gacy is known to have murdered.

According to Conti, Gacy may have killed while traveling for business, including areas where she believes it may have been easier to abduct people and dispose of bodies. Some of those other victims may even have Wisconsin ties.

“I got a call from a young person in Mequon, who said that a friend of hers went missing, age 14 or 15… he looked like one of Gacy’s victims. Same kind of build, blonde hair, it was after school” Conti said.

“And I knew that Gacy was in that area somewhat around that time.”

Conti also told Collins that she believes others may have been involved in at least some of the murders. She pointed to Gacy’s business records, which she said showed he was out of town for at least seven of the murders, and questioned whether people who lived with him could have been unaware of what was happening.

Listen to the full conversation.

More News

Wisconsin’s Weekend Morning News 8-23-26

Sunday Sip: Tabak Law

Tags: John Wayne GacyKaren ContiWisconsinWTMJ Conversations

Related Posts

Wisconsin’s Weekend Morning News
Homepage Showcase

Wisconsin’s Weekend Morning News 8-23-26

Homepage Showcase

Sunday Sip: Tabak Law

Pocket Neighborhoods, Grocery Store Pushback, and more Milwaukee Business News
News

A Kenosha car dealership under fire, a grocery store upgrade in Whitefish Bay, and more Milwaukee business news

Harry and Meghan return to England!
Homepage Showcase

Harry and Meghan return to England!

Next Post
Experience Wisconsin black background 2026

Fall in Rhinelander

LATEST NEWS

John Wayne Gacy mug shot

Did John Wayne Gacy have more victims? Former attorney points to Wisconsin cold case

Wisconsin’s Weekend Morning News

Wisconsin’s Weekend Morning News 8-23-26

Misiorowski outduels Sale and Contreras has big game in Brewers 2-1 victory over Braves

How you can meet The Miz and support a good cause!

Pocket Neighborhoods, Grocery Store Pushback, and more Milwaukee Business News

A Kenosha car dealership under fire, a grocery store upgrade in Whitefish Bay, and more Milwaukee business news

Harry and Meghan return to England!

Harry and Meghan return to England!

Latest Video

Rendering of Lighthouse data center in Port Washington. Photo courtesy of Vantage Data Centers

Data centers are shaping the governor’s race, but will it last?

Beagles rescued from Ridglan Farms enjoy grass for the first time on May 6, 2026. (Photo: Elisabeth Montemurro)

Ridglan Farms beagles find unlikely help inside Michigan prison

Whose poll is it, anyway?

Whose poll is it, anyway?

Johnson to seek third term

The national debt has surpassed $40 trillion; where is Congress?

WTMJ

© 2026 Good Karma Broadcasting.

Navigate Site

  • Careers
  • Contact
  • EEO PUBLIC FILE REPORT
  • FCC Public File
  • FCC Applications
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • WTMJ Timeline & History
  • Schedule
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contests

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
What's On Tap Weekends
ON NOW
What's On Tap Weekends Listen Live
  • Shows & Podcasts
  • News
    • Local
    • National
    • Crime
    • Government
    • Decision Wisconsin
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Education
    • Features
  • Weather & Traffic
    • Interactive Weather Radar
    • Interactive Traffic Map
  • Sports
    • Brewers
    • Bucks
    • Packers
    • Wisconsin Badgers
  • Partners
    • Shows
      • Drake & Associates Retirement Ready Show
      • The Fox World Travel Show
      • Joshing Around Milwaukee Podcast
      • Legally Speaking w/Hildebrand Law
      • Money Talk, The Annex Wealth Management Show
    • Featured Segments
      • At The Office with LAK Group & WTMJ
      • Every Day Health
      • Forward Thinking w/City Forward Collective
      • Siding Unlimited + Outdoor Living Unlimited
      • Steve Scaffidi’s Salute to Service
      • Sunday Sip
      • The Knowledge Brokers from R&R Insurance
      • Travel Wisconsin
      • WTMJ’s Home Improvement Showcase
  • Events
  • Contests
  • About Us
    • History & Timeline
    • Schedule
    • WTMJ Staff
    • Extra Points Newsletter

© 2026 Good Karma Broadcasting.