IRON COUNTY, Wis. — Truckloads of contaminated soil and water have been removed from a Line 5 spill site in northern Wisconsin as Enbridge crews work to clean up the largest natural gas spill in recent state history.
Enbridge has removed over 4,000 tons of contaminated soil and over 4,000 gallons of water mixed with firefighting foam from the construction site in the town of Saxon, where over 1.3 million gallons of natural gas liquids were released into the air after a line strike in August.
“Environmental monitoring remains ongoing,” Enbridge spokesperson Juli Kellner said in a statement to WTMJ. “Monitoring to date has shown no impacts to groundwater or wildlife.”
A report from a third party consulting firm detailed the results of soil and water sampling at the site: tests found volatile organic compounds (VOCs), chemicals related to petroleum products, and benzene above the state’s residual contaminant levels. The report says testing has not shown any impacts to surface water, private wells, or groundwater beyond the site.
Enbridge faces dozens of violations
The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources issued a formal notice of violations against Enbridge last month, alleging seven different types of violations related to water quality, air quality, and endangered resources protections.
The notice documents permit violations related to the Aug. 25 Line 5 spill, and others events including four drilling fluid releases (frac-outs) between March and September. It says Enbridge failed to use proper erosion and sediment controls at some construction sites.
The DNR also alleges that Enbridge violated state environmental laws when it began constructing a bypass around the Saxon Line 5 spill site to get the pipeline back into service, because the company did not obtain permits from the state first.
Enbridge could face fines, but only if the DNR refers the case to the Wisconsin Department of Justice for prosecution. Penalties could total tens of thousand of dollars per day for violations; meanwhile Enbridge reports billions in annual earnings.
Minimal efforts to pause Line 5 reroute construction
Although Enbridge has been hit with violations and temporary work stoppages immediately following the summer gas leak, no permits were revoked for the company’s larger Line 5 reroute project around the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa’s reservation.
Like financial penalties, halting construction requires a court order. The Line 5 reroute was given the green light in February, and reached the halfway point in August just before the Iron County spill.
Gov. Tony Evers has publicly made a statement demanding answers after the spill, but stopped short of declaring a disaster — a move which could also suspend or revoke permits.
The state of Michigan has stopped work on another Line 5 reroute project under the Straits of Mackinac. Construction has not begun on that project, as the state’s attorney general sues to shut down Line 5 altogether
Other investigations are ongoing involving Line 5 in Wisconsin, including a potential aquifer breach related to drilling for the pipeline reroute, and two instances of alleged arson that destroyed drilling equipment.












