Since its inception in 1935, the Heisman Trophy has recognized the best college football player in America.
More accurately, the award has – and continues to – recognize the best offensive college football player in America…with an emphasis on the quarterback and running back positions.
In 1997, Michigan’s Charles Woodson was unquestionably the best defensive player in college football. But to win over Heisman voters, Woodson also returned kickoffs, punts and played wide receiver.
In 2009, Nebraska’s Ndamukong Suh was the most dominant player in college football. Suh eared the AP College Football Player of the Year Award but finished a distant fourth in the Heisman Voting.
Since 1987, only four defensive players have finished in the top-4 of Heisman voting. Oklahoma’s Brian Bosworth in 1986 (4th), Washington lineman Steve Emtman in 1991 (4th), Notre Dame linebacker Manti Te’o in 2012 (2nd) and Ohio State edge LB Chase Young in 20129 (4th).
Emtman was the number-1 overall pick in the 1002 NFL draft. Young went number-2 in 2020.
Year after year, Heisman finalists are comprised of skill position players, with an occasional nod to the most elite defensive player. This year’s finalists include three quarterbacks and a wide receiver.
The award remains prestigious and exclusive. So why not call it what it is?
The Heisman Trophy recognizes the best offensive skill position player in college football.