By LARRY NEUMEISTER
Associated Press
NEW YORK (AP) — A judge said Friday that he’ll show a member of “The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City” some leniency when he decides how much time she must spend in prison for defrauding thousands of people nationwide in a telemarketing scam, many of them older. But he said he won’t grant her request that she only spend three years in prison.
The fate of Jennifer Shah was in the hands of U.S. District Judge Sidney H. Stein, who presided over her guilty plea in July to a conspiracy charge for participating in a massive fraud for nearly a decade.
At the start of Shah’s sentencing hearing, Stein said he won’t sentence Shah to the 11 years or more recommended by federal sentencing guidelines, but he also won’t grant a defense request that she only spend three years in prison.
He also cautioned a packed courtroom that he was not sentencing the person who people see on television.
Stein said that person is “simply a character. It’s acting.”
He said the housewives program “involves role playing … It’s a heavily scripted operation.”
Prosecutors said in a presentence submission that Shah should get a decade in prison, saying she used profits from her fraud to live a life of luxury that included a nearly 10,000-square-foot mansion with eight fireplaces dubbed “Shah Ski Chalet” in the resort haven of Park City, Utah. The home, they said, is now listed for sale for $7.4 million.
They said she also rented an apartment in midtown Manhattan, leased a Porsche Panamera, bought hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of luxury goods and funded various cosmetic procedures while cheating the Internal Revenue Service of hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Prosecutors attacked her behavior after her arrest on March 30, 2021, saying Shah lied to law enforcement in a voluntarily recorded interview before going on a reputation-cleansing public campaign in which she “repeatedly, vehemently, and falsely proclaimed her innocence.”
The government said she also seemed to mock the charges against her by claiming that the “only thing I’m guilty of is being Shah-mazing” and then she profited from it by marketing “Justice for Jen” merchandise after her arrest as she directed others to lie while trying to conceal her conduct from investigators.
The fraud, authorities said, stretched from 2012 to March 2021 as bogus services were promoted as enabling people to make substantial amounts of money through online businesses.
Meanwhile, defense attorneys minimized Shah’s role in the fraud in their presentence submission to the judge, saying there were “many, many people” involved in the long-lasting telemarketing scheme that led so many individuals to buy worthless services from companies in which Shah was involved.
They wrote that the fraud was “a mistake that has not only ruined her own life, but has broken her heart as she has watched the damage that her actions have caused.”
It was carried out, the lawyers said, “as part of an industry operating with a fine line between what is legal and illegal.”
“Ms. Shah was involved in both the legitimate and fraudulent sides of this industry,” her lawyers said.
Noting that one individual already sentenced in the fraud received more than seven years in prison, the lawyers said Shah wasn’t like codefendants who “are essentially career conmen; people who have spent their lives hopping from scheme to scheme; professional fraudsters without an honest dollar to their names.”
They added: “Before she committed these acts, Ms. Shah’s entire life, for more than four decades, was marked by hard, honest work, respectable achievement, and a hard-earned reputation for true generosity.”
Copyright 2023 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.
